How to Start a Compost Pile

When you are contemplating how to start a compost pile there are different factors to consider. We’re going to cover starting a compost pile, including: (1) location, (2) considerations for compost bins, (3) the composting method that is best to use, and (4) how to make compost by assembling and adding materials to make a compost pile.

Benefits of Compost

The benefits of compost include not only a slow release nutrient source for your garden, which is a fantastic organic fertilizer.  It doesn’t matter if you are growing tomatoes, purple potatoes, or roses, they all love compost.

In addition, it offers an array of other benefits that synthetic fertilizers (such as Miracle Grow) doesn’t offer, includes: increased water holding capacity in soil and the decomposition of toxins such as herbicides and pesticides, to name a few.

Making Compost Tea out of Compost

High quality compost can also be used in making compost tea. 

What compost tea is: Simply the extraction of the beneficial microbes from the surface of the compost and applying the compost microbes in liquid form onto plants and soil. It’s probiotics for plants!

How to Start Composting

First before you start a compost pile you need to determine what the best method of making compost is, based the quality of compost you desire and how much effort you want to put into making high quality compost.

Not all composting methods create that same quality of compost.

The best compost is that which is done using the hot composting methodComposting, from a professional standpoint, consists of decomposed organic matter,completed in the presence of oxygen and moisture.

Making a Compost Pile: Best Method

The hot composting method is simply the best way to start a compost pile, but it requires some work.  You build it all at once, must monitor it for temperature and moisture, and have to physically turn the pile.

When to Use a Static Pile

If you don’t think you’re going to want to work to make high quality compost and can be satisfied with making compost that may be full of weeds and even a few diseases, then the static compost is a far less labor intensive way to start composting.

Weeds in Your Compost

A static compost pile still involves work in assembling the materials but you don’t turn it.  I don’t recommend it since it ends up making weedy compost, and we spend enough time in our garden pulling up unwanted plants.

Compost Bin vs Compost Heap

When you are start a compost pile there are two main ways of making a compost pile: (1) a compost bin and (2) a compost heap.

If you want things neat and tidy and better able to control keeping critters out, then a compost bin is the way to go when you start composting. It’s the preferred method for most.  A DIY Compost Bin is an easy, quick and inexpensive way to start.

You will need: A pallet, stainless steel wire mesh for over the palette, several bungee cords, and 3′-4′ tall galvanized wire mesh (horse fencing). That’s it!

DIY Compost Bin

There are compost bins for purchase on the market, but they should be at least 3 feet x 3 feet in size and have good air circulation in order to be effective in making a compost pile.

A compost heap is simply a pile of materials placed directly on the ground (in an area with good drainage). Compost heaps are good at letting all the compost critters move in quickly and easily, but it’s hard to keep the unwanted critters such as rodents, raccoons and even dogs away from your compost heap. It’s also called “windrows”, which is what the professionals use as they have a compost turner.

windrow compost pile

 It’s also called “windrows”, which is what the professionals use, turning the pile with a mechanized compost turner.

What About Compost Tumblers?

Yes they are neat and are good at keeping unwanted critters out of the compost pile, but frankly they are terrible at making compost.  I had one for a couple of years and kept getting an undecomposted glob of materials as the end result.

It was either too wet or too dry and it had no way of letting all the beneficial microbes and other composting helpers into the pile. It also stank, which is the sure sign of it going anaerobic – the perfect environment for harboring plant diseases.

Talking about counter-productive. I ended up throwing the compost tumbler away.  Hindsight, I should have converted it into a worm bin, but I didn’t.

Yes, some municipalities require a closed container compost receptacle if you are in an urban area. However, you are better off purchasing one that stands on its own, has a cover, and has plenty of air spaces on the sides, and open in the bottom.

How to Start a Compost Pile: Location

Before you make a compost pile you need to consider the location of the compost pile. Here are a few guidelines:

  • It needs to be away from any stream or drainage
  • Ground should be level
  • In a convenient location, for easy access
  • Near a hose where you can water the compost pile on occasion
  • Enough space around the compost pile to turn the materials
  • Shady if you live in a hot, dry climate
  • Sunny location if you live in a cool, wet location

Too far away, then you are not motivated to give the compost pile the attention it may need. If the compost pile is assembled on uneven ground in a compost bin, then the compost pile may tip over.  No fun.  So when starting a compost pile, the initial location merits some thought.

How to Start a Compost Pile: Materials

When you are researching how to start composting you will hear about “green” materials  and “brown materials” for the compost pile.  Let’s break it down further into composting materials to make your compost pile even more successful.

Green Materials for the Compost Pile

how to make compost - green material

Green materials in the compost pile are what makes the compost pile heat up quickly and stay heated up in order for the material to be decomposed into material for your garden.  Green is also called “Nitrogen” and “High Nitrogen” material, and are materials that are harvested green or have a narrow carbon to nitrogen ratio.

High Nitrogen

High Nitrogen materials include manures, grains and nitrogen fixing plants such as alfalfa.  They are what “gets the party started” and will start your compost pile getting hot within a day or two.

They all have a narrow C:N ratio

Slightly less narrow carbon to nitrogen ratio green materials (materials that are harvested while still alive) include grass clipping, food scraps, hedge clippings, fruit and hay.  They are what keeps the pile hot and will assist in breaking down the organic material quickly.

It’s the green material that causes the pile go get hot, and as a result it must be turned to keep air circulating in the inside of the pile. Otherwise the microbes will use up all the oxygen and your compost pile will go anaerobic. 

Lack of oxygen (anaerobic conditions) foster the growth of disease and pathogens we don’t want ourselves or our plants exposed to. Anaerobic compost is not good for our garden – period!

You will need a good composting thermometer to monitor temperatures – 131 degrees for 3 consecutive days. Then turn the pile!

Brown Materials for the Compost Pile

how to start a compost pile - brown materials

Brown materials, also known as “Carbon” are materials that are cut dead and have a wide Carbon to Nitrogen ratio.  This includes wood chips, fallen leaves and straw.  Making a compost pile with leaves is a great way decompose all those fallen leaves quickly.  You can also stockpile the leaves in the fall in a compost bin and use it when you are ready to make the compost pile.

How to Start a Composting: Assembling the Materials

Here’s the next steps in making a compost pile:

  1. Determine how much material your compost bin will hold
  2. Assemble Green and Brown Materials per the volume of your compost bin.
  3. Wet all materials prior adding it to the compost bin
  4. Mix all the materials together prior to adding it to the compost pile

A couple of things to Note:

Moisten the Compost Pile Materials

starting a compost pile - wet materials

Next, when starting a compost pile all the materials need to be thoroughly wet.  Soak any wood chips the night before. 

The organisms responsible for making compost need moisture to do their job.  However to saturate it since too wet can lead to anaerobic conditions. Target about 40-50% moisture.  That’s about 1-2 drops of moisture coming out of the materials when squeezed between the fingers.

Mix Materials BEFORE Assemblying Compost Pile

This may seem a bit contrary to what the mainstream “lasagna” method of a static compost pile tell you to do, but mix all the materials together FIRST before adding it to the compost bin.

How to make a compost pile


In order to start a compost pile correctly, you want to mix the browns and green together so that all the materials get broken down into compost.

When you layer the materials there will be pockets where decomposition doesn’t take place.  I find it best to mix all the materials first on a tarp, and even better when you have a group of friends to help you out.

starting a compost pile - mix materials first

Final Step: Monitoring & Turning

After all the materials have been added to the compost bin, the compost pile should be covered.  This keeps moisture in, particularly if you live in a hot dry climate. It also keeps the rain out which may saturate your compost pile, making it go anaerobic. 

If you have composting problems, you may need to disassemble the pile and start again. With hot composting this will set you back only 15-30 days.

Next, to start a compost pile, you will need to monitor it for temperature and moisture. The pile will need to be turned at least 3 times in order for the outside material to receive the heat treatment. This is necessary for all weed seeds and potential disease to be killed.

making a compost pile - monitor and turn

How to Make a Compost Pile: Don't Forget

  1. When you are done with your compost, after it has cooled, you will need to sift it to get out the large chunks.Use a compost sifter.
  2. Then, don’t forget to add the mycorrhizal inoculum. It’s the plant’s hidden partner essential for finding nutrients for the plant. It even helps the plants talk to each other!

Inspired? Pin it!

Please note: The products we recommend are real recommendations, but the links to Amazon are affiliate links where we may earn a small commission. This helps cover the costs of running Positively Sustainable. It does not affect your price. Thanks for your support!

Composting & Gardening

Organic Gardening

composting leaves

Composting Leaves

Composting Fall Leaves In the fall, the time for composting leaves is ideal. We’ve got lots of them and so instead of going into the

How to compost manure - chicken cow horse

Composting Manure

Composting Manure for Your Garden How do you begin composting manure, whether it be chicken manure compost or for composting horse manure?  Many people that

Learned Something? Share it!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on stumbleupon

More to explorer

At Positively Sustainable, we are committed to providing information that will help you to make confident choices about the products you buy. We believe in the power of ethical consumerism to hold businesses accountable and make sure that they are manufacturing products in an environmentally and socially responsible way.

Join us on our journey towards a positively sustainable future.

8 thoughts on “How to Start A Compost Pile”

  1. Pingback: Being Green and Composting

  2. Pingback: Starting my first compost pile

  3. Pingback: Jeff M

  4. Pingback: Woody Mendochino

  5. Pingback: Jaime

  6. Pingback: Jeffry Mattus

  7. Pingback: Carolyn

  8. Pingback: Sarah K.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.