making great compost

23 Composting Tips | Composting Guide Do's and Don'ts

This article we provide 23 composting tips, which will help you whether you are a seasoned gardener or just beginning.  These composting tips will help make great compost from your compost pile.

If you have composting problems, check out this article on composting solutions to 10 common problems:

Composting Tips: Must Dos

  • Build a compost pile that is at a minimum of 3 feet by 3 feet in size. A few DIY Compost bin styles will help guide you on the right compost bin for you.
  • Elevate your compost bin on a palette to keep it well aerated on the bottom, and allow for good drainage.
  • The best compost is made by the hot composting method. Using this method all the materials are added at once and you don’t add to the pile. If you have kitchen scraps, worm composting is a better bet.
  • To keep unwanted seeds out of your worm compost, heat the kitchen scraps in a microwave first to kill all seeds.
More tips for composting
  • Green materials such as manure can be stored and used in the compost pile at a later date if you dry them out first. If you store them without drying them out they become moldy and unusable. This just one composting tip on how to compost.
  • Store composting materials in garbage cans with lids keeps the composting area neat and tidy. It also helps in measuring out your volume of compost materials when you are building the compost pile. Most experienced gardeners love this composting tip – try it!
  • Always keep your compost moist. Pre-wet all materials before adding it to the compost pile. This composting tip will keep the composting microbes happy. When a compost pile dries out the composting process shuts down and the materials are not readily decomposed. Target 40% moisture content.  Particularly pay attention to the outside of your compost pile since this tends to dry out quickly. Leaves for composting are particularly dry.

Composting Tips: Air Needed, Avoid Critters

    • Keep your compost pile aerated. Following this composting tip, this means you will need to turn your compost pile since all the hard working compost microbes will use up the oxygen and your pile will go anaerobic in the middle. Anaerobic conditions foster plant diseases – so that would be bad if you added anaerobic compost to your garden! Turn your compost.
    • If you live in an area where you have lots of critters such as raccoons, mice, rats or even bears, then a great composting tip is to leave all meat scraps as well as kitchen scraps out of your compost pile. This will keep the unwanted critters from foraging in your compost.  Use a compost cover such as wire mesh or fabric.
    • To keep the compost in a neat and tidy area, use a compost bin that has a lot of air circulation. Avoid compost tumblers since they do not aerate well and do not make great compost.

Composting Tips: Starting, Plant Needs, Finishing

  • Add compost starter and other micronutrients when building the compost pile. Micronutrients are often limiting in soil and by adding it to the compost it will be well incorporated when you are ready to spread it on the garden. Most experienced growers keep this composting tip a secret!
  • Make compost that is specific to the type of plant you are growing. Compost for trees and shrubs will use a different recipe than compost for most vegetables or lawns.   Use more brown materials than green for when you are making compost for trees and shrubs.
  • Compost should be applied in the fall, after you have harvested the food in your garden. Compost becomes well incorporated naturally by soil organisms throughout the fall and through to the spring.  Be sure to add mycorrhizal fungi to the finished compost.  They help plants find nutrients and can help your tomato varieties also share resources.

Composting Tips: Don't Do This!

Avoid these things when composting
  • Your compost pile should be in an upland, dry area, not near a water source. Any leachate coming from the compost pile may negatively affect the water quality in nearby streams and ponds.
  • A compost pile built on a slope can cause you big headaches, because a large compost pile can tip over and make a mess!
  • Composting made with animal scraps is possible, but it will heat up your pile considerably and you will need to turn the compost frequently.  Use a Compost Thermometer. An unturned compost pile with a lot of animal scraps can go anaerobic and anaerobic conditions foster the development of plant diseases. You don’t want that type of compost in your garden or around your trees and shrubs.
  • A compost pile that is too wet can go anaerobic. Don’t overwater the compost. This composting tip alone will help you make high quality compost. Composting material should have an overall moisture content of about 40%. 
  • Invasive species are a huge problem. We don’t want to spread species that are overly aggressive and can take over.  Unless you are really experienced in the hot composting method, don’t add invasive species to your compost pile. This includes such species as pampas grass, fountain grass and kudzu.  Environmentalists will appreciate it if you follow this composting tip.
  • Unless you are a really experienced composter and using the hot composting method, don’t add dog poop or human waste to the compost pile. This composting tip is essential. Dog and human waste can harbor pathogens. The hot composting method will kill the pathogens, but if you don’t compost correctly they will not be killed.

Composting Tips: Avoid These Mistakes!

  • Unfinished compost will kill your plants. This is because the composting microbes are still needing the nitrogen to break down the materials.  If you add it when they are still working, they will suck the nitrogen from the soil and there will be none left for your plants. Thus your plants will die (of malnutrition)! 
  • A rule for determining if compost is finished or unfinished is if it is hotter than ambient air temperature, it’s not ready!
  • Certain pesticides and herbicides are not broken down in a compost pile. Many are decomposed, but not all. To be safe, avoid compost material that has been treated with toxic substances.
  • If you are not using the hot compost method, seed heads from unwanted plants should be removed prior to placing it in your compost pile. The hot composting method will kill seeds but any static compost pile or worm compost will not kill weed seeds.
  • To make high quality compost quickly you will need to monitor, and turn the pile. Don’t ignore your compost pile. Check on it regularly.

Composting Tips: When Your Compost is Ready

  • Be sure to sift your compost before adding it to the garden. The large woody chunks can be used for mulch around trees and shrubs
  • Add the mycorrhizal fungi. Your plants will thank you for it!
  • Compost should be added to the top of the soil in the fall. It can also be mixed into potting soil at the beginning of the season.

Inspired? Pin it!

42 composting tips. Composting mistakes to avoid, composting best practices to implement
Please note: The products we recommend are real recommendations, but the links to Amazon are affiliate links where we may earn a small commission. This helps cover the costs of running Positively Sustainable. It does not affect your price. Thanks for your support!


Organic Gardening

How to compost manure - chicken cow horse

Composting Manure

Composting Manure for Your Garden How do you begin composting manure, whether it be chicken manure compost or for composting horse manure?  Many people that

composting leaves

Composting Leaves

Composting Fall Leaves In the fall, the time for composting leaves is ideal. We’ve got lots of them and so instead of going into the

How to Start A Compost Pile

How to Start a Compost Pile When you are contemplating how to start a compost pile there are different factors to consider. We’re going to

What compost is and how it benefits your plants

What is Compost?

What is Compost? The compost definition is simply the decomposition of organic material in the presence of oxygen. More technically stated to it is the

What are the best composting materials you can use?

What Materials Can I Compost?

Composting Materials – What Materials Are Best? What materials can I use in compost?  This is a question we get all the time when teaching

Learned Something? Share it!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on stumbleupon

More to explorer

At Positively Sustainable, we are committed to providing information that will help you to make confident choices about the products you buy. We believe in the power of ethical consumerism to hold businesses accountable and make sure that they are manufacturing products in an environmentally and socially responsible way.

Join us on our journey towards a positively sustainable future.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.